David’s Big Ideas for Therapy (Pt. 2):
Homework, Depression, and Resistance
Hosts:
Dr. David Burns
Kevin Cornelius, LMFT
Guest:
Jeremy Karmel
What if one of the biggest obstacles to successful therapy isn’t the severity of a person’s depression or anxiety, but something much simpler: their willingness to do the work?
And what if the very things that seem to sabotage therapy—hopelessness, resistance, and even refusing to do homework—actually hold the keys to recovery?
In this episode of The Feeling Good Podcast, Dr. David Burns, Kevin Cornelius, and special guest Jeremy Karmel continue their exploration of the revolutionary ideas behind TEAM-CBT.
Together, they tackle three powerful concepts that challenge conventional thinking about psychotherapy:
- Treatment Is an Active Process: Why talking about your problems may not be enough to overcome them.
- Depression Is a Con: How distorted thoughts can trick us into believing things about ourselves that simply aren’t true.
- Resistance Is the Cause of Most Therapeutic Failure: Why trying harder to convince someone to change can actually make change less likely.
Along the way, David shares unforgettable stories from his clinical career, describes research that transformed his approach to psychotherapy, and demonstrates techniques that can turn resistance into genuine motivation for change.
1. Treatment Is an Active Process: Why Therapy Homework Matters
David begins by contrasting traditional, relatively passive approaches to psychotherapy with the active, skills-based approach of TEAM-CBT.
He recalls his early psychiatric training, when patients might spend session after session discussing their suffering, expressing painful feelings, and exploring their pasts—without necessarily making meaningful progress.
David became increasingly frustrated by an important unanswered question: How do we actually help patients get better?
His search for an answer led him to emphasize psychotherapy homework—practicing new ways of thinking, feeling, and behaving between sessions.
But there was a problem: many patients simply refused to do it.
David tells the remarkable story of an anesthesiology resident whose resistance to homework became so intense that she threatened suicide if he ever asked her to complete another assignment. After spending two additional years working with her without meaningful improvement, David began to rethink his entire approach.
He developed what he called the Self-Help Memo, establishing a clear expectation that patients would actively participate in treatment by practicing therapeutic skills between sessions.
He also describes research from his clinic showing a striking relationship between homework completion and recovery from depression. In his study, patients who refused to do any homework showed no improvement during the first 12 weeks of treatment.
These experiences led David to develop two important therapeutic techniques:
- The Gentle Ultimatum: Clearly and compassionately explaining what participation in treatment requires, while respecting the patient’s freedom to choose.
- Sitting With Open Hands: Offering help without pressuring, persuading, or attempting to control the patient.
Kevin and David demonstrate how these techniques can be used with a patient who wants to feel better but refuses to do homework.
Rather than arguing, David expresses warmth and respect, explains the potential benefits of treatment, and makes it clear that the decision belongs entirely to the patient.
The surprising result? David found that when he stopped trying to convince patients to do homework and began holding them accountable with kindness, many became more motivated to participate.
2. Depression Is a Con: The Lies We Tell Ourselves
Next, the conversation turns to one of David’s most provocative ideas: Depression is a con.
What does he mean?
David explains that depression is fueled by negative thoughts that feel absolutely true but are often filled with cognitive distortions.
Consider thoughts such as:
- “I’m a failure.”
- “I’m not good enough.”
- “Nobody could ever love me.”
- “My life is hopeless.”
When we’re depressed, these thoughts can seem like undeniable facts. Yet David argues that they often represent deeply unfair and inaccurate judgments about ourselves.
He shares the example of a highly accomplished psychiatrist who, despite her professional success, became severely depressed following a romantic rejection. She began telling herself that she was a failure as a mother, a psychiatrist, and a human being.
David identifies several cognitive distortions operating in her thinking, including All-or-Nothing Thinking, Overgeneralization, Discounting the Positive, Emotional Reasoning, and Self-Blame.
The tragedy is that we often speak to ourselves in ways we would never dream of speaking to someone we love.
David also discusses research involving the Feeling Good and Feeling Great apps. He describes findings supporting the cognitive model of depression, including evidence that reductions in negative thinking are associated with improvements in emotional distress.
The central message is both simple and hopeful:
When people learn to recognize and stop believing distorted negative thoughts, their painful feelings can change dramatically.
The challenge is that these thoughts can be extraordinarily convincing, especially when someone is deeply depressed.
And that brings us to the third big idea.
3. Resistance: Why We Fight Against the Changes We Want
If distorted thoughts are making us miserable, why do we sometimes fight so hard to defend them?
David argues that unrecognized and unresolved resistance is responsible for much of the failure we see in psychotherapy.
He distinguishes between two kinds of resistance:
Outcome Resistance: Part of the patient doesn’t want to give up the problem or painful feeling, even though another part desperately wants relief.
Process Resistance: The patient wants to get better but doesn’t want to do what treatment requires, such as completing homework or practicing exposure exercises.
David illustrates this with a story about a medical student who believed she was stupid despite earning outstanding grades in every class. Even when Aaron Beck presented overwhelming evidence of her academic abilities, she found a way to maintain her negative belief.
Why would someone cling so tightly to a belief that causes such suffering?
The answer, David suggests, is that our negative thoughts and feelings often have hidden advantages and reflect important personal values.
For example, hopelessness might seem to protect us from disappointment. Refusing homework might express a desire for independence, autonomy, or freedom from being controlled.
Instead of attacking these forms of resistance, TEAM-CBT therapists learn to understand and appreciate them.
A Live Demonstration: Turning Resistance Into Motivation
Jeremy volunteers to play a discouraged patient who refuses to do homework because he believes he’s a hopeless case.
David begins with empathy, carefully acknowledging Jeremy’s frustration, discouragement, and disappointment with therapy.
Then he does something unexpected.
Rather than trying to persuade Jeremy to change, David explores the advantages of remaining hopeless and avoiding homework.
Together, they identify several positives:
- Hopelessness reflects Jeremy’s desire to be realistic after years of unsuccessful treatment.
- Avoiding homework allows him to enjoy his free time.
- Refusing assignments demonstrates independence and a refusal to be controlled.
- Maintaining low expectations protects him from further disappointment.
David then uses a paradoxical approach, taking the side of not changing and gently reminding Jeremy of all the good reasons to remain exactly as he is.
Something remarkable happens.
Jeremy begins arguing for change.
He explains why he wants to feel better, why he might be willing to complete homework, and why remaining hopeless isn’t the life he wants.
David hasn’t convinced Jeremy of anything. Instead, Jeremy has discovered his own motivation.
Kevin highlights the brilliance of this approach: By respecting resistance rather than fighting it, the therapist creates an opportunity for the patient to become the strongest advocate for change.
David concludes by explaining why these techniques can be difficult for therapists to master. Our natural impulse is to help, rescue, reassure, and persuade. Yet these well-intentioned efforts can sometimes strengthen the very resistance we’re trying to overcome.
The alternative is to listen deeply, honor the patient’s autonomy, and allow motivation to emerge from within.
Key Takeaways
- Effective therapy requires active participation. Lasting change often depends on practicing new skills between sessions, rather than relying exclusively on conversations during therapy.
- Accountability and compassion go hand in hand. The Gentle Ultimatum and Sitting With Open Hands allow therapists to establish clear expectations without coercion or judgment.
- Depression can make distorted thoughts feel like facts. Recognizing and challenging inaccurate negative beliefs is central to David’s cognitive approach to emotional recovery.
- Resistance isn’t necessarily the enemy. Negative feelings, beliefs, and behaviors may reflect meaningful values or offer perceived benefits. Understanding these hidden positives can open the door to change.
- Stop trying to convince people to change. Through empathy, Positive Reframing, and paradoxical techniques, therapists can help patients discover their own reasons to pursue recovery.
- The patient’s autonomy is essential. Successful TEAM-CBT involves collaboration, honesty, and respect—not forcing someone to accept treatment they don’t want.
Article Reference
Burns, D. D., & Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (1991). Coping styles, homework compliance and the effectiveness of cognitive – behavioral therapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59(2): 305 – 311.
Final Thoughts
This episode challenges a deeply ingrained assumption about psychotherapy: that the therapist’s job is to persuade, rescue, or somehow fix the patient.
David offers a radically different vision.
The therapist brings expertise, powerful tools, empathy, and hope. The patient brings the freedom to choose whether and how to participate.
And sometimes, the most powerful thing a therapist can do is stop pushing for change.
Listener Survey
We’d love to hear from you!
Your feedback helps shape future episodes and allows us to create content that is as helpful and meaningful as possible. Please use this link to take the feedback survey and share your thoughts with us about this episode.
Thank you for listening to The Feeling Good Podcast!
Contact Information
Kevin Cornelius, LMFT is a Level 5 Certified Master TEAM-CBT Therapist and Trainer and the Clinical Director of Feeling Good Institute–Silicon Valley. He specializes in the treatment of trauma, anxiety, depression, relationship problems and insomnia. You can reach Kevin at kevin@feelinggoodinstitute.com and visit his website at www.tools4change.me.
You can reach Dr. Burns at david@feelinggood.com.
Feeling down in these turbulent times? Take a ride on our Feeling Great app.
Feeling Great feels wonderful!
You owe it to yourself to feel GREAT!
Give the Greatest Gifts of ALL–Love and Happiness!
